Are you in the process of choosing a WordPress recipe plugin for your food blog or recipe website?

With a wide range of brands and options available, it's understandable to feel overwhelmed. That’s why we made this list – so you can make the most informed decision possible.

We’re here to help. So we’ve scoured the internet to find out exactly what food bloggers are saying about the WP Recipe Maker WordPress plugin. 

Let’s get into it.

1. Limited Customization Options

People using the WP Recipe Maker plugin have complained that it’s difficult to customize the recipe layout or make it match the look and feel of their website. 

If you're looking for a WP Recipe Maker alternative, consider Tasty Recipes.

Of course, when you make a food blog, you want it to look perfect! The secret is customization.

That’s why Tasty Recipes has six beautiful recipe card template options to showcase your creations. Plus, it picks up styles from your WordPress food blog theme to make the recipe look “at home” on your website. You have complete customization control with our WordPress recipe templates. 

Here are some of the customization options offered:

WP Recipe MakerTasty Recipes
Background colorTitle color
Text colorBackground color
Social media footer textIcon color
Instructions text color
Heading text color
Button text color
Social media footer (can choose which SM platform)
Social media footer color
Social media footer text
Star rating stylization 

2. Poor User Interface

Some bloggers find WP Recipe Maker’s user interface to be unintuitive and difficult to use. “Interface” refers to the options and tools you use within the plugin. It’s the way in which you interact with the technology in front of you. 

The extra time learning how to use WP Recipe Maker can take away from the time spent creating. You’re a blogger, not a coder or web developer.

Tasty Recipes dashboard

With Tasty Recipes, you can end the headache of complicated, frustrating plugins that are hard to use. It streamlines your blogging workflow. Now you can spend more time creating and publishing recipes your readers will love. This makes it a great WP Recipe Maker alternative.

3. Limited Free Recipe Features

WP Recipe Maker has fewer free features compared to other recipe plugins. This can be frustrating for bloggers looking for more advanced recipe options.

Check out the advanced features you get with Tasty Recipes:

  • Unit Conversion: Switch between US customary and metric for your recipe ingredients with unit conversion buttons.
  • Jump to Recipe and Print Recipe: Optional jump and print links at the top of the post.
  • Recipe Scaling: Adjust serving sizes using the 1x, 2x, and 3x buttons.
  • Embedded Video Tutorials: Step-by-step video integration that can be turned on/off by readers
  • Affiliate Links: Showcased equipment and products through Tasty Links
  • Hands-Free Feature: Cook Mode makes it easier for readers to follow along with your recipe while they're cooking.
  • Nutrition Facts: Easily add recipe nutritional information with or without our Nutrifox nutrition API integration.
  • Copy to Clipboard Button: Readers can copy/paste the ingredients list in one click.
  • Shoppable Recipes: Instacart button, to make your recipes shoppable and give you commissions for ingredient links.
  • Social Sharing: Added Instagram, Facebook, or a Pinterest handle. Let visitors tag you when they try your recipe or share it online!

4. Incompatibility With WP Themes

WP Recipe Maker may not work well with all WordPress themes, causing compatibility issues.

Any one of our six beautiful recipe card designs will effortlessly blend into your posts. Tasty Recipes works with ANY theme or plugin for WordPress. 

5. Limited Customer Support

Some bloggers have reported slow or inadequate support from WP Recipe Maker's customer service team. This has made it difficult to troubleshoot issues or get help with customization.

If you’re looking for unmatched performance and customer support, all Tasty Recipes users receive personalized customer service from Day 1. There is no jumping through hoops to talk to a real person to get your needed support. 

6. Inconsistent Recipe Formatting

Bloggers have reported that WP Recipe Maker's recipe formatting can be inconsistent, leading to an incorrect or inconsistent display of ingredients and instructions.

Whether you’re working in Classic Editor or Block Editor, the Tasty Recipes interface makes it easy to publish recipes. 

example recipe with Tasty Recipes

Your recipe card must offer an enjoyable experience for your visitors — consistent formatting, clearly laid out recipes, an organized ingredient list, and step-by-step instructions — that's all standard.

7. Difficulty Importing Recipes

Bloggers have reported issues with importing recipes from other sources or plugins, which can be time-consuming and frustrating.

Moving from one recipe maker to another can be a big pain, especially if you have multiple recipe collections. The last thing you want to do is convert your recipes manually or one by one. 

With Tasty Recipes, we make it easy to convert your recipes from dozens of other recipe platforms.

Here’s a list of everything kept when you import your recipes to Tasty Recipes, whether it’s from WP Recipe Maker, Recipe Card Blocks, or any other recipe plugin:

  • Recipe title
  • Summary
  • Featured image
  • Ingredients (in bulleted list form)
  • Instructions (in numbered list form)
  • Bold & italic text
  • Links (including nofollow links)
  • Prep time & cook time
  • Notes
  • Yield & serving size
  • Nutrition facts
  • Recipe ratings (star ratings)
  • Images and videos

Your recipes are imported with all these elements, whether you’re using the free version or the premium version of another plugin. You can convert recipes individually for testing and then in bulk, once you are ready.

8. Slow Website Speed

Some bloggers have reported that WP Recipe Maker can slow down their website, particularly when displaying multiple recipes on a post or page.

Tasty Recipes has everything you need and nothing you don't. It's optimized for site speed, providing you with the power of structured data and features your readers will love — but without the feature bloat that would otherwise slow you down.

9. Limited Nutrition Information

In a WPRM recipe, you may only be able to have basic nutrition information. This may not be enough for those who need more detailed information.

Tasty Recipes includes fields for complete nutritional data, from calories to saturated fat and everything in between. 

You have two options:

  • You can even integrate your recipe cards with Nutrifox, a tool that allows you to easily create and customize recipe nutrition labels. 
  • Or, of course, you can calculate the nutrition details with your favorite tool and fill out the fields in the recipe edit modal.

10. Cost

Whether you’re considering the WP Recipe Maker Premium WordPress plugin (or WP Recipe Maker Pro), these premium plans require a subscription, which may not be cost-effective for everyone, particularly those with smaller blogs or websites.

However, when comparing pricing, Tasty Recipes does offer more bang for your buck – and even allows you to use the plugin on multiple sites for less. When you join the WP Tasty Fam, you can say goodbye to monthly subscriptions and hello to having a well-performing food blog that you and your readers will love.

Best of Luck!

Making a decision on the right recipe plugins can be a crucial part of your food blog or recipe website's success. And when it comes to the success of your website, you don’t want to take any chances. 

A well-presented recipe can not only make your audience come back for more but can also encourage them to share your content with others! Therefore, it's vital to make an informed decision that suits your needs and goals. We hope this list has helped you in this process.